Judy Moffett ([info]hefngafr) wrote,

A review! A very palpable review!

I thought I knew all the bad things about self-publication. (I did know so many that it took me a VERY long time to decide to go that route.) Turns out there are lots of bad things I didn't have a clue about till they happened, and one of them is that none of the trade journals will review you. Not Library Journal, not Kirkus, not Booklist, not PW even if one of their regular reviewers requests the book--doesn't matter how much they loved your other books. So I am extremely happy to report that The Bird Shaman has had its first review, by Kilian Melloy, in the online gay magazine EDGE: Boston. Herewith, a snippet for your delectation:

"This book is the long-awaited third installment in a trilogy that also includes the novels The Ragged World and Time, Like An Ever-Rolling Stream. It’s not necessary to be familiar with the previous books to enjoy The Bird Shaman; author Judith Moffett works all the background relevant to the story at hand into the course of the narrative, creating a seamless and complete novel that stands alone quite nicely.

"Part of the reason this book succeeds so well as its own work comes from how well Moffett allows the tenets of her story to guide the character and the parameters of the world she builds, a place characterized by horse-drawn carriages as well as by exotic technological advances. In the process, Moffett explores the equally alien worlds of the extraterrestrials who rule earth with a heavy guiding hand, and the vanished tribes of indigenous Americans whose rock art provide the only clue to the visions that may have given cultures long vanished a glimpse at humanity’s dubious future."

Check out the full treatment at

http://www.edgeboston.com/index.php?ch=entertainment&sc=books&sc2=reviews&sc3=fiction&id=79685
Tags: edge:boston, reviews, self-publishing

  • Post a new comment

    Error

    Anonymous comments are disabled in this journal

    Your IP address will be recorded 

  • 7 comments

[info]realthog

August 30 2008, 03:48:14 UTC 3 years ago


Congrats on such a good review -- nice one!

Yes, it's depressing how PW and the rest will give review space to any old crap published by HarperCollins or Random and ignore simply give no coverage whatsoever to much that's published by smaller presses. Monopoly abuse, anyone? My first story collection, issued by a small press, was ignored entirely by PW despite being given a longish rave review in Locus. Some disconnect, surely.

[info]hefngafr

August 30 2008, 12:52:44 UTC 3 years ago

Thanks for the congrats and commiserations. I'm told there will be a review in the October Locus, which sure is a whole lot better than nothin'--I wasn't sure Locus would review a POD either, and won't be absolutely sure till I see it!

From my battered perspective, a very small press is still an order of magnitude better than DIY, at least in the dignity department.

[info]realthog

August 30 2008, 17:14:52 UTC 3 years ago


"I'm told there will be a review in the October Locus"

Oh, congrats in advance on that one! Fingers crossed it's a rave.

I think Locus is pretty open-minded about PoD publications. Come to think of it, they must be or they'd've had to ignore, just for starters, the entirety of the Wildside/Prime list until recently.

"From my battered perspective, a very small press is still an order of magnitude better than DIY, at least in the dignity department."

I know what you mean. I'm still surprised there weren't people jumping to take you on.

[info]hefngafr

August 30 2008, 17:27:24 UTC 3 years ago

"I'm still surprised there weren't people jumping to take you on."

Thanks--very nice of you to say that, but it's all about the numbers and Time, Like an Ever-Rolling Stream didn't sell well.

[info]realthog

August 30 2008, 21:14:24 UTC 3 years ago


Yeah, the idiocy of the modern books biz. But I'd've still thought a medium/smaller press would have been keen to take you on.

[info]hefngafr

August 30 2008, 21:58:52 UTC 3 years ago

All I can say is, I really tried, and they really weren't, and I got really really tired of hearing No. Maybe if I'd kept trying...hard to say.

Anyway, I appreciate your views on the subject.

[info]realthog

August 30 2008, 22:21:45 UTC 3 years ago


"I got really really tired of hearing No"

I know the feeling!
Create an Account
Forgot your login or password?
Facebook Twitter More login options
English • Español • Deutsch • Русский…